Skip to Main content
  • Black Pony Pizza




About Us


Pizza the best way, Detroit style.  We serve up a small but tasty menu with new featured pizzas consistently.  Or you can build your own using the ingredients we keep on hand.  


Ryan has been in commercial kitchens for over a decade.  He started making pizzas between prep and service and soon, he started bringing his pizzas to parties with family and friends.  Their favorites are how we decided on our menu.  But Ryan hasn't stopped at five recipes so we'll be rotating new recipes throughout the year, the best of which you'll see more frequently.      


We're located in The Short North, specifically North High Street and West Starr Street.  On the Corner.  West Starr is in between West 2nd Avenue and West 3rd Avenue.      

FAQ


What hours are you open?

We are closed Monday-Wednesday

Thursday: 4pm - 9pm

Friday: 4pm - 10pm

Saturday: 11am - 10pm

Sunday: 11am - 8pm


Do you cater?

Yes!  Even though we are not open during lunch hours during the week we are happy to cater your work and personal events.  Because of our kitchen size, orders larger than 10 pizzas require a 24 hours lead time due to space constraints.  If your order falls within our normal operating hours, we do not require any additional lead time.


Do you deliver?

At the moment, we only offer carry out.  As we grow we plan to introduce delivery through one or more of the popular delivery services available to customers.  Don’t worry, delivery is coming and we will be shouting it from the roof tops.


Do you accept cash?

We do not accept cash or check payments with the exception of catering orders.  We accept all major credit/debit cards, Apple Pay, PayPal, and Venmo.


Black Pony Pizza Location and Hours

(614) 564-9277
1001 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201
Open now • Closes at 10PM
Instagram logo
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement